Experience relaxation at Nicolet Shores Resort in Phelps, WI, featuring a sauna, hot tub, and swimming pool. Rated 4.6 with nearby lakes and easy airport access.
Visitors appreciate the resort’s scenic location, recreational options, and family-friendly atmosphere, while noting some outdated furnishings and occasional maintenance issues.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Nicolet Shores Resort is a lakeside retreat nestled in Phelps, Wisconsin, offering a range of amenities suited for relaxation and outdoor activities. The property features access to a sauna, an indoor pool, and a hot tub, along with facilities such as racquetball courts. Its location on Spectacle Lake provides opportunities for kayaking, canoeing, and fishing, appealing to guests who enjoy nature and water-based recreation.
With a 4.6 rating from 68 reviews, the resort is praised for its peaceful setting within the Nicolet National Forest and its well-maintained grounds. Visitors appreciate the quiet atmosphere, beautiful natural surroundings, and availability of equipment like row boats and paddle boards. Units include full kitchens, adding convenience for longer stays and family visits.
While the resort is generally well-regarded, some guests note that certain furnishings and decor feel outdated or mismatched, and maintenance issues have been mentioned. Nevertheless, many return annually, valuing the balance between privacy and proximity to nearby towns like Eagle River for shopping and additional activities.
The area around Nicolet Shores Resort offers several interesting destinations such as North Twin Lake, Kentuck Lake, and the nearby Spectacle Lake itself, all popular for outdoor exploration. Travelers arriving by air can access the property within about an hour from Rhinelander–Oneida County Airport or slightly longer from Ford Airport, making it fairly accessible despite its secluded vibe.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
Kids and I had a great time. 3 piers to fish and launch boats from. They have row boats and kayaks to use. An indoor pool and hot tub. And board games available also. Lots of stuff to do while here!
We had a wonderful time here. Great to relax and enjoy the beauty of the snow on the massive pine trees. The resort was clean and well maintained. The units are beautiful. My husband and I would greatly recommend checking it out for yourself. Nice pool, fitness room, jacuzzi and ping pong and pool. We loved it.
Fantastic northwoods hidden gem. Quiet and secluded right on beautiful spectacle lake. Most affordable vacation experience around. All units have full kitchens. It's like having a vacation home! Absolutely love the resort and the staff!
Nicolet Shores is a wonderful retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. My family has been coming here since it was built. We've had five generations over time stay on the property. Spectacle lake is the perfect blend of recreation and privacy. The resort amenities give you something different to do everyday for all ages, from kayaking to tennis and so much more!
Nicolet Shores is a really nice place to visit. My parents have been owners since it first opened in the 80's. The positives are that it's a really nice setting on a lake in the Nicolet National Forest. It's very secluded & quiet, but not far to drive to Eagle River for shopping. The negatives are that it is quite outdated. The furniture is either old or uncomfortable. Things are mismatched. The A/C wasn't working in our room & management just brushed it off by saying the unit is too small for the large room. So what's the answer to that problem? Seems like an easy dilemma to solve. Other than those small dilemmas, I'd recommend going & spending a quiet week in the northwoods.
Quiet place to enjoy nature. Updated condos that are nicely furnished. Kayaks, canoes, paddle board, and row boats are available for use. 30 minutes from Eagle River, so opportunity for a shopping day. Great family place! We love it and return year after year.
For years, we exchanged a timeshare elsewhere to vacation at Nicolet Shores Resort. It dawned on us, when a perfect fixed week became available, to jump on it. We now own two weeks at NSR. We love it! The scenery is breathtaking! The lake is quiet. Eagle River is close by. The other owners are gracious and friendly. If you love the outdoors, you will love staying at Nicolet Shores!
There are so many words to describe Nicole Shores Resort. One word is peaceful. My closest friend and love had the most amazing experience. He and I had this resort as our center and we explored. So many wonderful hikes/nature in the area. Coming back to center after our adventures, Nicolet Shores Resort helped to enhance and summarize our days. Clean! Pool, hot tub, our room, everything, clean! And the staff; kind, kept your privacy and always gracious. Thank you!
Based on sightseeing, recreation, and getting around
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Wisconsin. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
9 reviews Wisconsin, USA
19 reviews Wisconsin, USA
16 reviews Phelps, WI 54554, USA
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Relax at Prytania Park Hotel, featuring free WiFi, breakfast, and parking. Located near The National WWII Museum and Jackson Squa...
Relax at Best Western Plus Coachella Valley Inn & Suites in Cathedral City with free WiFi, breakfast, heated pool, fitness center...
Stay at Embassy Suites by Hilton Birmingham Hoover, featuring free breakfast, indoor pool, gym, and LGBTQ+ friendly amenities near...
Stay at Hampton Inn & Suites Spokane Valley with free breakfast, indoor pool, fitness center, and easy access to Riverfront Park. ...
Stay at Ambassador Hotel Wichita, Autograph Collection. Luxe rooms, free WiFi, steakhouse, 24hour gym & local shuttle near Centur...
Stay at Clinton Inn & Suites in Port Clinton, OH. Enjoy budgetfriendly comfort with free breakfast, seasonal pool, and easy acces...
Stay at ASHLEY INN Motel in Ponca City, OK with free WiFi, parking, and petfriendly rooms. Close to E.W. Marland Mansion and Pio...
Stay at Home2 Suites by Hilton Hayward with free WiFi, parking, outdoor pool, and petfriendly rooms. Close to Oakland Zoo and Re...
Stay at Hilton Garden Inn Shelton, featuring free WiFi, indoor pool, and petfriendly rooms near Yale University and Beardsley Zo...
Straightforward rooms with free WiFi, breakfast & gym. Close to Blue Heron Nature Center and historic sites in Ridgeland, SC. Rat...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
